Don’t be fooled by a high dividend yield, do your own research

By: ispeculatornew
Date posted: 06.09.2010 (4:43 am) | Write a Comment  (8 Comments)

      Post a Comment

Every month, we publish the list of the top 100 Dividend Yields in the S&P500. We have also published lists of the top dividend ETF’s and yesterday I did some research to see who was currently at the top of that list.  The one on top is PPH, a Pharmaceutical Holders Trust, which came out with a dividend yield of 12.67%. That seemed high didn’t it? Having done the top 100 dividend stocks just a few days ago, I was pretty confident the dividend yield did not make sense. So I looked around the web and other websites such as Bloomberg and ETFreplay had the same very high yield.

What is PPH?

The Pharmaceutical HOLDRS Trust issues depositary receipts called Pharmaceutical HOLDRS, representing an undivided beneficial ownership in the United States-traded common stock of a group of specified companies that are involved in various segments of the pharmaceutical industry.” First off on my list to look into the dividend yield was understanding PPH. What is inside of it? How much dividends do the underlying stocks pay? Many ETF’s and almost all funds only reveal their positions in quarterly reports but some others such as this one gives out details every day (mostly because this specific one does not change over time in “normal circumstances”). So I went on the official website and the list of stocks was right there, easy to get:

TickerNamePricePE RatioPE Next YearReturn YTDSales GrowthAnalyst ratingBook ValueBetaRevenue/ShareSales 5Y Avg GrowthEPS 5Y Avg Growth
PCLNPriceline Group Inc/The1575.1327.0621.569.299.264.64199.321.25181.0820.759.49
TWTRTwitter Inc17.62N/A28.283.9358.092.856.491.483.3599.28N/A

Most of these stocks pay decent dividend yields but nowhere near the yield that PPH has paid in the last year. First off, I went to get out the current dividend yield for all of the stocks that constitute PPH:

TickerNamePricePE RatioPE Next YearReturn YTDSales GrowthAnalyst ratingBook ValueBetaEarningsRevenue/ShareSales 5Y Avg GrowthEPS 5Y Avg Growth
AAPLApple Inc132.4215.813.114.5-7.734.5424.811.214/25/201739.4211.5612.27

So no, there is no way for an ETF that includes all of these stocks to pay out 12.67% of dividend yield as not even one of the stocks inside of it pays that amount.

So what happened then?

I decided to take a look at how PPH dividends are paid out. Turns out that it is even easier than most ETF’s. Every single time one of its stocks becomes ex-dividend, PPH also becomes ex-dividend. So yes it ends up  paying multiple dividends in  a few days sometimes. For example, PPH will become ex-dividend on June 11th, a dividend of 0.10928$. Where does that amount come from? Take a look at this chart with a bit more details:

TickerNamePricePE RatioPE Next YearReturn YTDSales GrowthAnalyst ratingBook ValueBetaRevenue/ShareSales 5Y Avg GrowthEPS 5Y Avg Growth
ETSYEtsy Inc12.9N/A59.279.6839.833.833.061.893N/AN/A
NFLXNetflix Inc142.22338.1260.1514.7130.263.956.231.4620.5923.4695.62

On June 11, Merck & Co will become ex-dividend. If you multiply the number of shares per unit x the payout= 0.3007 x $0.39 = $0.117

PPH will be paying $0.1093, which seems to include some fees (contrary to many funds, PPH and other Holders Trust pay fees through their dividends since they do not have cash).

So what is the catch?

What screws up  everything is that PPH had a special one time payment of $1.47 in November 2009, a payment that greatly influenced the dividend payout but is not likely to repeat and is certainly not sustainable. So no, PPH’s true dividend yield is nowhere near 12.67%.

So what is PPH’s dividend yield?

It would simply be the sum of each stock included dividend yield x it’s weight in the ETF. Take a look at the chart below:

TickerNamePricePE RatioPE Next YearReturn YTDSales GrowthAnalyst ratingBook ValueBetaRevenue/ShareSales 5Y Avg GrowthEPS 5Y Avg Growth
ETSYEtsy Inc10.66N/A38.73-9.2533.443.672.971.883.21N/AN/A Inc848.91173.3644.9713.7627.084.7440.431.21286.8920.2453.25

So what is PPH’s dividend yield? A still respectable 3.17%. Nowhere near the number presented above but still good enough to consider investing. So please be careful when investing in an ETF or any other stock by basing yourself only on the dividend yield, there is much more to it.

If you liked this post, you can consider subscribing to our free newsletters here


  1. Comment by The Financial Blogger — June 9, 2010 @ 11:01 am

    Interesting how you can analyse a dividend yield.

    Is there a quick way to get the information on the distribution throughout the year? I guess you are better off with the financial statements?

  2. Comment by Matthew — June 9, 2010 @ 12:17 pm

    Some people based their income projection on dividend yield. I think you are better off being conservative when doing so since the company can’t cut their dividend at any time.

  3. Pingback by LinkStuff For Thursday, June 10 — June 10, 2010 @ 3:02 am

    […] The Intelligent Speculator warns about being fooled by a high dividend. […]

  4. Comment by IS — June 10, 2010 @ 4:37 am

    @TFB – Thanks:) Getting these informations is surprisingly complicated, I’m not quite certain why. I will try to find better and easier ways in the coming months!

    @Matthew – They CAN cut their dividend yield I guess you mean? Yes absolutely. I think it’s important to do some research. I now send out more detailed research in the newsletter every month to go along with the top dividend stock picks published here.

  5. Comment by Bud Davidge — June 11, 2010 @ 3:50 am

    Interesting. I recently invested in a Brompton
    Fund –Lifeco Split (LCS on TSX) it’s dividend
    is 18.87% I’m wondering if something similar is going on here?

  6. Comment by IS — June 11, 2010 @ 8:53 am

    @Bud Davidge – I do not know much about the company however what I do see is much lower. In the past year, it has “skipped” or “omitted” almost half of its dividends which brings its dividend yield under 10%. Without having spent more time, I’d say you should do more research yes, because this does not look as good as an 18.87% dividend:(

  7. […] be fooled by a high dividend yield, do your own […]

  8. […] portfolio is built, it can be maintained with little effort. Of couse, as we wrote in the past, it’s not always about getting the highest dividend yield but you can look at our list of top dividend yields.  The goal is twofold here: Building a […]

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.