Build your own macro hedge fund with Single Country ETF’s

Pierre Cantin By: IS
Date posted: 07.21.2010 (4:00 am) | Write a Comment  (6 Comments)

Print This Post Print This Post    Email This Post Email This Post    Post a Comment

One of the more popular forms of active investing is macro economy based on the different economic news around the world. The three major investment arenas are commodities, currencies and international stock/bonds. I personally have always been interested in the third one through my traveling.

That being said, such investing used to be reserved to fund managers because of the complexity involved. First there were tax issues as every country has different laws that made it very complex and costly to invest in. But even bigger challenges came from operational issues:

-opening accounts in foreign countries
-currency conversions
-specific rules for foreigners
-etc

ETF’s save the day

As many of you know I am a big fan of ETF’s for many reasons but the amazing variety of ETF’s now makes it possible for almost anyone to get involved into International investing. Buying the entire stock market (more or less) of a country is something that can now be done in any brokerage account. Gradually, these ETF’s have gained popularity and while Ishares remains the biggest player thanks in large part to the fact that it was first in the game, others have made inroads in offering products in other countries. Just take a look at the map below to see all of the alternatives out there:

Also, I thought it could be interesting to take a closer look at the relationship between the actual macro-economic performance of these countries and the performance of the various ETF’s. There are other factors of course that could contribute including currency movements. But it is still an interesting exercise to do in my opinion. Also, even on an individual country level, the relationship between GDP and stock market performance is far from direct. All of this is because stock market performance is generally not related to actual economic performance but rather the actual economic performance compared to what was anticipated.

Without further wait, you can see the actual map , as you can see there are a lot of choice when it comes to single country ETF’s :

Best GDP Growth in 2010

RankCountry2010 GDP growth
1Singapore10.5
2China10.1
3Taiwan8.6
4India8.6
5Malaysia7.1

Best GDP Growth over 5 years

RankCountry20062007200820092010Average
1China12.714.29.69.110.111.14
2India9.839.57.486.738.68.428
3Vietnam8.28.56.25.36.56.94
4Peru7.768.859.9416.056.72
5Egypt6.97.17.24.75.26.22

Best Single Country ETF’s  so far in 2010

RankTickerNameMarket CapPriceReturn YTDFees
1IDXMarket Vectors - Indonesia Index ETF $384,859,000.00 73.8321.0230.71
2THDiShares MSCI Thailand Index Fund $279,220,500.00 47.2915.0580.65
3EWDiShares MSCI Sweden Index Fund $200,025,800.00 25.2814.1370.55
4EWMiShares MSCI Malaysia Index Fund $591,563,200.00 11.7113.1950.56
5ECHiShares MSCI Chile Index Fund $464,880,000.00 58.710.8190.65


Best Single Country ETF’s in the last year

RankTickerNameMarket CapPriceFees1Y Return
1IDXMarket Vectors - Indonesia Index ETF $384,859,000.00 73.830.7158.171
2RSXMarket Vectors - Russia ETF $1,768,248,000.00 29.220.6251.483
3TURiShares MSCI Turkey Index Fund $436,465,500.00 57.330.6550.44
4THDiShares MSCI Thailand Index Fund $279,220,500.00 47.290.6545.216
5EWDiShares MSCI Sweden Index Fund $200,025,800.00 25.280.5541.733



And finally you can see the entire data set for the countries that have an ETF:

Country200320042005200620072008200920102011
United States2.53.63.12.72.10.4-2.43.12.9
Brazil1.175.713.163.976.085.17-0.186.554.5
China1010.111.312.714.29.69.110.19.25
Japan1.42.781.932.032.35-1.18-5.233.251.7
Taiwan3.676.194.75.445.980.73-1.918.64.5
Canada1.893.123.022.832.20.53-2.463.63.1
South Korea2.84.645.25.12.30.25.34.4
Australia3.23.683.22.64.732.381.352.953.45
Hong Kong38.57.176.42.1-2.75.74.6
Russia7.47.26.47.78.15.6-7.94.054.2
Singapore2.937.56.588.257.81.9-1.2510.55.1
United Kingdom2.832.22.82.7-0.1-4.91.22
Germany-0.21.20.83.22.51.3-4.91.91.6
Malaysia5.86.85.35.86.54.7-1.77.14.9
South Africa2.954.535.285.585.53.73-1.753.153.6
Turkey8.811.79.575.7-1.2-7.25.454
Chile3.845.915.634.534.812.76-0.944.55.2
Switzerland-0.22.532.633.683.61.8-1.4522.1
France1.12.51.92.22.40.2-2.61.31.4
Spain3.13.33.643.60.9-3.6-0.450.7
Indonesia4.785.045.75.56.286.084.555.86.2
Thailand7.16.34.65.14.92.5-2.25.254.4
Israel1.5155.15.285.240.73.14.05
Sweden2.53.73.154.583.43-0.58-5.052.352.6
Peru4.124.996.827.768.859.9416.055.35
Italy01.50.721.5-1.3-50.91.1
Belgium0.61.12.61.532.811.31.7
Netherlands0.32.223.43.62-41.22
Mexico1.343.24.93.31.5-6.54.43.6
India7.337.259.239.839.57.486.738.68.8
Vietnam7.37.88.48.28.56.25.36.57.5
Poland3.85.43.46.26.851.82.93.5
Egypt3.14.156.97.17.24.75.26
Ireland4.354.636.085.355.63-3.5-7.55-0.42.95

And for those ETF’s

TickerNameMarket CapPriceReturn YTDFees1Y Return
SPYSPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust $68,924,140,000.00 $106.66(0.70)0.094519.859
EWZiShares MSCI Brazil Index Fund $8,829,180,000.00 $64.15(10.97)0.6529.267
FXIiShares FTSE/Xinhua China 25 Index Fund $7,669,296,000.00 $38.74(4.64)0.733.834
EWJiShares MSCI Japan Index Fund $4,617,684,000.00 $9.35(0.83)0.564.679
EWTiShares MSCI Taiwan Index Fund $2,793,960,000.00 $11.83(7.09)0.6513.026
EWCiShares MSCI Canada Index Fund $3,432,936,000.00 $25.681.210.5522.035
EWYiShares MSCI South Korea Index Fund $3,183,968,000.00 $46.371.730.6530.57
EWAiShares MSCI Australia Index Fund $2,174,596,000.00 $20.04(8.44)0.5524.876
EWHiShares MSCI Hong Kong Index Fund $1,444,756,000.00 $15.15(0.15)0.5512.799
RSXMarket Vectors - Russia ETF $1,768,248,000.00 $29.22(3.11)0.6251.483
EWSiShares MSCI Singapore Index Fund $1,564,596,000.00 $11.815.330.5530.565
EWUiShares MSCI United Kingdom Index Fund $956,800,000.00 $14.59(5.74)0.5514.17
EWGiShares MSCI Germany Index Fund $1,438,353,000.00 $20.12(6.79)0.5512.707
EWMiShares MSCI Malaysia Index Fund $591,563,200.00 $11.7113.200.5633.447
EZAiShares MSCI South Africa Index Fund $490,716,000.00 $56.473.090.6622.844
TURiShares MSCI Turkey Index Fund $436,465,500.00 $57.3310.340.6550.44
ECHiShares MSCI Chile Investable Market Index Fund $464,880,000.00 $58.7010.820.6530.492
EWLiShares MSCI Switzerland Index Fund $390,165,000.00 $20.92(1.39)0.5621.7
EWQiShares MSCI France Index Fund $253,228,000.00 $21.25(12.99)0.558.691
EWPiShares MSCI Spain Index Fund $160,184,200.00 $36.97(18.15)0.56-1.265
IDXMarket Vectors - Indonesia Index ETF $384,859,000.00 $73.8321.020.7158.171
THDiShares MSCI Thailand Index Fund $279,220,500.00 $47.2915.060.6545.216
EISiShares MSCI Israel Capped Index Fund $166,980,000.00 $48.09(7.65)0.6619.767
EWDiShares MSCI Sweden Index Fund $200,025,800.00 $25.2814.140.5541.733
EPUiShares MSCI All Peru Capped Index Fund $205,034,500.00 $33.726.840.6336.591
EWIiShares MSCI Italy Index Fund $90,499,500.00 $15.29(17.80)0.55-0.864
EWKiShares MSCI Belgium Investable Market Index Fund $57,549,050.00 $11.77(3.69)0.5617.56
EWNiShares MSCI Netherlands Investable Market Index Fund $143,262,300.00 $18.72(4.41)0.5524.722
EWWiShares MSCI Mexico Investable Market Index Fund $1,536,657,000.00 $48.993.920.5536.422
INPiPath MSCI India Index ETN $957,642,800.00 $63.971.610.8932.377
VNMMarket Vectors Vietnam ETF $146,038,200.00 $24.77(0.67)0.76N/A
PLNDMarket Vectors Poland ETF $34,751,000.00 $22.16(5.86)0.65N/A
EGPTMarket Vectors Egypt Index ETF $3,496,000.00 $17.48N/A0.94N/A
EIRLiShares MSCI Ireland Capped Investable Market Index Fund $3,058,500.00 $20.10N/A0.55N/A

What does the future hold?

It is certainly fascinating to see the possibilities with all of these ETF’s. That being said, I expect many more ETF’s to eventually open. First off, many countries will probably soon get their own ETF, here are some of them:

Argentina
Colombia
Czech Republic
Denmark
Greece
Hungary
Iceland
New Zealand
Norway
Philippines
Portugal
Venezuela

And also, I would expect bond ETF’s to become a lot more diversified. You can buy Chinese or Brazilian stocks, why can’t we buy Chinese government bonds or Brazilian corporate bonds? I’m convinced that over time these will also appear in the market.

And finally, this has already started but I expect many more specialized ETF’s to appear. For example, you can trade all of these sub-sectors in China. I would expect that would be available in other countries over time.

Conclusion

Not a big surprise but the relationship between GDP and ETF performance seems weak in many cases but the most obvious case is China which has had an amazingly strong economy but the ETF’s that track the Chinese market have performed very poorly which is normal since the Chinese market has indeed suffered a great deal this year. Are you surprised by these results? Have you tried out any of these single country ETF’s?

Similar Posts:

More on this topic (What's this?)
Measuring the Performance of the Ivy Portfolio
25 things you should know about ETFs
Read more on Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) at Wikinvest
If you liked this post, you can consider subscribing to our free newsletters here


6 Comments »

  1. Comment by Zavi — July 21, 2010 @ 8:45 am
    Zavi

    Good post!! Yes I am really surprised. The stock market is usually influenced by the state of the economy. Can you give me the 3 countries with the lowest relationship between ETF’s performance and GDP’s growth? And the 3 countries with the highest relationship. Thanks!

  2. Comment by The Financial Blogger — July 21, 2010 @ 1:50 pm
    The Financial Blogger

    would you buy according to the GDP or the recent stock market performance?

  3. Comment by IS — July 23, 2010 @ 4:03 am
    Pierre Cantin

    @Zavi – Wow, very difficult one !! The correlation seems very low across the board, would have to work on that, maybe at some point later!

    @TFB – according to the P/E and other fundamentals of the stock market, not the GDP.

  4. Carnival of Personal Finance #267 @ Beating Broke

    [...] Pierre from Intelligent Speculator presents Build your own macro hedge fund with single country ETFs. [...]

  5. Adding a sovereign debt ETF to your passive income/dividend portfolio « Intelligent Speculator

    [...] writing about the single country ETF’s, I had mentioned that I anticipate a lot more ETF’s tracking foreign debt to be released in [...]

  6. Will long term EEM investors please stand up? « Intelligent Speculator

    [...] and capture virtually all of that market. Over time, more specialized ETF’s that cover either individual countries or even sub-sectors of those countries started to appear.But to most long term investors, trading [...]

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL


Leave a comment